Judge.me Review Medals

Over the years, the number one thing we strive for is to know that people find our boots comfortable & durable.

Until your pair arrives & you can feel it for yourself, take their word for it...

Based on 683 reviews
88%
(599)
8%
(53)
1%
(9)
2%
(11)
2%
(11)
J
Kern
Jesus Estrada (Los Angeles, US)
Excellent boots

Comfort, style and durability
Definitely looking forward to another pair, best boots I’ve owned
100 out of 10 recommend

R
Kern
Rob P. (San Diego, US)
Many Compliments on these Boots

AFter bringing a question to Customer Service, I supremely pleased with the attentiveness of Wilcox and recommend them to my team. I wear them daily in my office. They are amazingly comfortable and durable. And when broken in, fit like fine leather gloves.

T
Kern
Toby (Yuma, US)
Almost perfect

I really like these boots. They are my first nice pair of boots. They took a week or so to break in, but they weren’t super uncomfortable during the break in period. I would have given them five stars but I heard the pull strap tear when I went to put them on when they were new and stiff. No visible damage but still worries me a bit. It was probably my fault. I have on more than one occasion been accused of forcing something big into a small opening.

J
Kern
JoseLuis Lopez
Great Boots

These boots are great. Really comfortable and durable. The leather upper is really tuff and resistant to scuffs and scratches. The inner lining is nice and soft aswell. The insole is more than just your basic insole it's got lots of cushion. The XL Extralite sole is great too lots of grip but not too stiff like some thick clunky rubber soles. I use my boots inside walking on hard concrete surfaces and I have no problem with my feet at the end of the work day. These boots are good for any occasion work or going out.

B
Fairfax
Brent (Berwyn, US)
Really like these boots

This was my first pair of Wilcox boots. Didn’t know how to size them…. Took two tries to finally get the right size but customer service was great. Once I got the the right ones they have been awesome. Wear them often. Well made, look sharp and really comfortable. Will be a repeat customer.

H
Nº 08 Loop Keychain
Harriet B (Brunswick, AU)
Perfect for my keys

These keychains hold all my keys and hang on the hooks next to my front door with ease. The leather is such high quality that it hasn’t stretched while hung on hooks for long periods.

K
Shiloh
Kasim Abuaisheh (Suwanee, US)
7 years in…

Best boots I’ve ever purchased. I’ve had these for 7 years. I took them to an old school shoe shop to have them cleaned and they were extremely impressed by the boot. I expect another 10 years out of these. Comfortable, rugged, all around best shoes I’ve ever purchased

J
Fairfax
John Krizan (Shawano, US)
Best boots ever

I was always looking for a traditional man’s boot a boot a man from the 30’s
Or 40’s would be familiar with.
Your boot fits that bill. The pig skin lining is a added plus for comfort. I will always chose quality over Chinese crap.

G
Shiloh
Geoffrey Koch (San Diego, US)
Great so far!

I just received mg Shiloh’s a few weeks ago and have been wearing them a lot over the past week while helping my friend remodel some bedrooms. The biggest thing I appreciate is that these boots provide support without destroying my feet while they break in, no rubbing at all! I have also gotten several complements on them which is always nice. I can tell they are very sturdily made and look forward to wearing them for many more years.

D
Shiloh
Daniel (Queens, US)
Excellent

So...I was definitely unsure if I should purchase...but I did. The boots are extremely comfortable, and become more comfortable the more I wear them. They look great. One day they were too hot, so I may refrain from wearing them when it's a little warmer out. My only real complaint is that the treads don't look like they will last a long time. It would definitely have been better to write this review in a few months to see how long the treads will last and how well the boots will keep. As far as size, I went with the same size of my other shoes, and it's a perfect fit. Overall, I am very satisfied, even knowing that I will need the treads replaced in a few months. I get lots of comments and I am looking forward to seeing how they will hold up.

J
Fairfax
Jacques Pereira (Califon, US)
3rd + Pair of boots

I have owned Wilcox boots since 2017. 2 x Shiloh rust brown (one is now a work pair and a newer not as beat up pair) and 1 x Fairfax Black. These are the most comfortable boots I have ever worn. Not only do they feel good, they also look great. As they break in, they seem to stretch a bit making it easier for thicker socks if you are working or hiking outside. I recently had my black Fairfax resoled and shined up, and they look like new.
I also just bought my son a pair of Century's for Christmas so he has a nice pair for college. - so far so good!
The only item that is annoying is some of the quick lace hooks have broken from wear and tear, which either can be repaired or you can slip the laces through the hole..no biggie.
Do yourself and your feet a favor and buy a pair, you will not be disappointed.

A
Shiloh
Andrew Roman
BUY THEM

You will not regret buying these boots, I have two!

S
Shiloh
Scott Herber (Vernon, US)
2nd Pair

These are the first pair of boots or shoes that I had ever purchased over the internet. I bought my first pair to wear while hanging out in the great outdoors or working in the yard, it wasn't long that I was wearing them for everyday use. They are now ready to be resolved. I didn't want to go without so I have just received my second pair. I plan on using the new pair for my everyday boot and the resoled pair for my outdoor wear. They are very comfortable, broke in quick. I highly recommend Wilcox boots.

P
Shiloh
Paul Hewitt (Martinsburg, US)
Awesome!

Stunning boots. I’ve never had leather..anything this nice. Heavy, but comfortable with minimal break in necessary. My only qualm, the soles have gaps between the layers, as if they’re separating. I contacted Wilcox, and they assured me they wouldn’t separate any further. But at the price point I’d love to not see those cracks -_- Alas, overall, awesome boots. Thank you.

T
Fairfax
Tony Fish (Fowlerville, US)
Best Boots

Very comfortable and great Quality.

Reviewer avatar
Shiloh
Roland Tanedo (Catonsville, US)
Like a wild stallion,you got to tame them.

i have travelled across the seas with my first pair 10 years ago and ‘im about to have it resole . I waited a sale on black friday and bought another 2 pairs of Shiloh . It’s the most comfortable boot’s anyone can buy in the market. its worth to a hard earned money to invest on a good pair of boots.

G
Shiloh
Guy Wilcox (Fayetteville, US)
Comfortable and clean up very well.

I actually bought a pair of these used on Ebay just to test them before I thought about buying a new pair. Here are some before and after shots of using simple brown shoe polish and buffing. They clean up extremely well. I own Redwing Blacksmith and Wolverine 1000 mile boots. They are fantastic boots, but these are far more comfortable.

S
Shiloh
Seth Horwitt (Klamath Falls, US)
Great Boots!

Great boot! I purchased both the Fairfax and the Shiloh. Very well constructed. Great looking boot. Don't hesitate to get a pair. The Fairfax runs a bit narrow in the toe box, but they stretch. The Shiloh actually has a better fit. I'll probably be getting another pair of the Fairfax on brown. Very pleased!!

S
Shiloh
Stan Mayhew (Atlanta, US)
After 3 years,What do I think?

I've had my Shiloh's for about 3 years and they've been possibly the best shoes/boots I've ever owned. They've been amazingly comfortable from day one. And now they're even more comfortable than my tennis shoes. This may be the year I get new treads on them but they have lots of life left in the leather. I may even get a 2nd pair just to have a clean pair to wear as causal dress.

B
Kern
Bo Aragon (Las Vegas, US)
Beware of these boots

Beware of these boots because they’re made for more than walking and you’ll probably end up with two pairs just like I did. Comfort, craftsmanship and style are a 10/10. Money well spent!

D
The 1.5" Belt
Drew L (Charlotte, US)
Everyday Belt!

This belt has been my go to everyday since I got it. Durable leather, classic style, fit is fine ordering one up from my pant size.

D
Century
Drew L (Charlotte, US)
Beautiful, tough service boots

These are phenomenal boots at a great price! I am happy to put them on my feet in the morning and enjoy them all day when I wear them.
The leather is smooth and takes a nice brush shine. Seems a high quality, strong leather. It is a bit stiff at first, it took some oiling and a dozen or so wears to feel broken in. I consider this a sign of strong structured leather that is now fit to my foot.
The soles are branded Wilcox but look otherwise like a Dainite sole. I’ve never worn Dainite style soles before. I find them to be stiffer than I like, but they provide good traction in most situations and don’t pick up a lot of mud. I’ve enjoyed that they are easy to clean as I frequently find myself on construction sites.
The fit was spot on sized as my normal athletic shoes. I did find the width, or more precisely the height under the bottom of the tongue to be a bit snug for me. I tried stretching them with thick socks and a bit of water, but not much luck. I removed the standard insole and got enough room for a good fit. Even without the insole I find the comfortable on my feet.
These boots also have a good weight, lighter than most I’m familiar with in similar styles.
Buy a set - I bet you’ll be pleased!

S
Fairfax
Scotty
Still going strong

I bought these a few years ago and use them hard. (Harder than I should've to be honest. Hunting, hiking, motorcycle, farm.) They look even better with time. I've had them re-soled once,(hunting trip in hard/wet conditions ripped off the heel.) Still love them whether polished or not.
Only gripe is the back/forth shipping took a while and the insert that came w/ them was virtually useless, just a piece of fabric almost.
(I got my own inserts,) and that was all they needed.
I've considered buying a 2nd pair but don't want to spend the dough yet.
I've had other friends purchase, and I'm glad we all have.
Most of the time they're not polished.

A
Shiloh
ANDY DE LA O (Phoenix, US)
Didn't Work for Me

Great boots, well made...but they killed my feet, felt like my feet were burning. Maybe it's the New Mexico desert but I don't know. Started the warranty return, wish they would have worked.

T
Fairfax
Thomas R (Streamwood, US)
Get off the fence!

These boots are super comfortable with minimal break in period if you do it right. I personally put on thicker socks and wore them around the house for 30 minutes of walking, and wearing them 2 times and that’s all it took. I have two pairs of Fairfax boots, one in black and one in rust. I also have a pair of rust Shiloh boots and they are all very well made, comfortable look great and will last you for years to come. Without sounding like I work for Wilcox, buy them!! (I don’t work for or have any affiliation with Wilcox.)

I forgot to mention, I have a pair of brown Kerns on the way!